| |
Fish Oil vs Flaxseed Oil
Although the body can
convert alpha-linolenic acid, a short-chain omega-3 fatty acid, from
flaxseed oil,
it
is much more efficient to get EPA and DHA from fish oils. Furthermore,
there is evidence that many people, particularly many men, have a
difficult time converting alpha-linolenic acid to EPA and DHA. Also,
the long-chain omega-3 fatty acids, but not alpha-linolenic acid
the chief component of flaxseed oil, are also transformed into
regulatory compounds known as prostaglandins. These compounds carry
out many important tasks in the body. They regulate inflammation,
pain, and swelling; they play a role in maintaining blood pressure;
and they regulate heart, digestive, and kidney function.
Prostaglandins also participate in the response to allergies, help
control transmission of signals along the nerves, and help regulate
the production of steroids and other hormones. Through their effects
on prostaglandins and related compounds, long-chain omega-3 fatty
acids can mediate many physiological processes making them useful in
virtually every disease state as well.
Michael T. Murray has this to say:
My opinion on the superiority of longer-chain omega-3 fatty acids over
alpha-linolenic acid is not new. I have always held that if
manufacturers could solve some of the problems with commercial sources
of EPA and DHA that I would wholeheartedly recommend them over
flaxseed oil. The reason that I favored flaxseed oil over fish oils in
some of my books (e.g., Encyclopedia of Natural Medicine) was because
at the time the books were written there were major problems with fish
oil supplements.
However, a new development has changed my perspective.
New Developments
The ability to produce a highly concentrated form of long-chain
omega-3 fatty acids that is free from lipid peroxides, heavy metals,
environmental contaminants, and other harmful compounds.
These "pharmaceutical grade" marine lipid
concentrates are so superior to earlier fish oil products that they
are literally revolutionizing nutritional medicine. The key
features of this product over other fish oil products include:
- More than twice
the level of EPA and DHA per capsule than most brands.
- Each capsule
provides 600 mg of long-chain omega-3 fatty acids (400 mg EPA/200 mg
DHA)
- Quality control
steps to insure the product is free from lipid peroxides, heavy
metals, environmental contaminants, and other harmful compounds.
- Ratio of omega-3
fatty acids to arachidonic acid > 50:1
- Contains the
optimal amount of natural vitamin E as a preservative.
Fish oil, mercury, and
heart disease
Two highly publicized studies in 2002 demonstrated quite conclusively
that fish consumption can reduce heart disease. The first article,
published in the JAMA (Journal of the American Medical Association)
showed that there was a clear relationship between dietary intake of
fish and omega-3 fatty acids and the likelihood of developing coronary
heart disease - the higher the omega-3 fatty acid intake, the lower
the likelihood of coronary heart disease. This relationship was even
stronger for coronary deaths. The second article, published in the New
England Journal of Medicine, looked at omega-3 fatty acid levels in
blood as opposed to diet. The investigators found a striking
relationship between the blood level of omega-3 fatty acids present
and the follow-up likelihood of dying from coronary heart disease.
The Latest Study
While fish oils may protect against heart disease, the latest study
raises an important question - Is the benefit of eating fish
counteracted by a higher intake of mercury? Mercury has been known to
increase the risk of cardiovascular disease. Because fish intake is a
major source of exposure to mercury, the mercury content of fish may
counteract the beneficial effects of its n-3 fatty acids. Results from
another study published in the New England Journal of Medicine show
that while higher body levels of fish oils were associated with a
decreased risk for heart attacks, the higher the body mercury level
the greater risk of a heart attack. Researchers concluded that the
high mercury content of fish may diminish the protective effect of
fish intake against heart disease.
The Solution
Using a pharmaceutical grade fish oil supplement is the perfect
solution to people wanting the health benefits of fish oils without
the mercury and other contaminants found in fish. It is estimated that
the use of fish oil supplements may reduce overall cardiovascular
mortality by as much as 45%. This effect is not related to a change in
blood cholesterol levels. The favourable effect is seen very rapidly,
usually by three months into the study. In contrast,
cholesterol-lowering drugs do not usually show benefit until after a
year or more of therapy. As compared to drug therapy, omega-3 fatty
acids provide remarkable benefits, are entirely safe, and are
inexpensive.
Dr Barry Sears
Recommends
For general health, take 200 to 400 mg of EPA and 100 to 200 mg of DHA
daily (this is found in a 1000mg softgel of pharmaceutical grade fish
oil). It is best to take the supplements at the beginning of the meal.
For therapeutic indications the dosage is to triple this dosage.
Click here to
order
|
|